
ARISTOTLE'S NOTION ON CHANGE AND PERMANENCE
CHAPTER ONE
1.0 Background Of The Study
1.1 Introduction
The sense of wonder is the mark of the philosophers. Thus, according to Aristotle, “all men by nature desire to know”1. On the same note, philosophically and otherwise, man has to give meaning to the mysteries befogging his finite nature. Therefore it is not out of place that we are dragged into the concepts and facts of change and permanence.
To the philosophers then, this omnipresent fact of change and permanence offered a paradoxical challenge stretching from the ancient Greek philosophy, through the medieval and modern, down the contemporary period. Succinctly put, the problem of change and permanence is as old as philosophy itself hence according to Popkin, R.H:
Greek thinkers were impressed with the two basic features of the world, the occurrence of natural change and the continuance of certain apparently permanent conditions.2
The earliest Greek thinkers attempted to work out explanations of reality by asserting that underlying all the apparent changes; there is real, unchangeable element. The motive behind this inquiry as highlighted by Mullin E. was that,
…If the many could be seen in some way as instances of one, it would then be sufficient to grasp the one.3
Thus reality is one thing, which however, appears in different guises at different times.
Against this background, some thinkers proceeded by way of action and reaction and delved into formulating theories in view of the enigma of change and permanence. The problem they grappled with was prompted by fact of material change, and the principle they posited were arrived at through observation and thought. “For Thales, reality was water, for Anaximander, it was the ‘boundless’ or the infinite; and for Anaximanes, it was air.”4 In the history of Greek thought these earliest thinkers were called the pre-Socratics. Referring to them, Copleston observed that,
…We can already discern in them the notion of unity in difference and of difference as entering into unity.5
Hence, Heraclitus consolidated change at the expense of permanence while Parmenides argued that, “absolute change is impossible and unthinkable and by nature things are permanent.”6 So for Heraclitus, all things flow; nothing abides, thus, “one cannot step twice in the same river”.7 Whereas Parmenides states that change, becoming or motion is impossible, because they would involve both non-being and being which being contradictories, cannot both be. Thus, according to Parmenides, “Being is; non-being is not.”8 The position of these two champions gave rise to the great controversy on change and permanence, which arose as to how things can change and yet remain the same. It was in an attempt to solve this ‘excruciating’ problem in philosophy that Aristotle came up with his principles of act and potency, Hylemorphism and categories (substance and Accidents).
However, in change what takes place is neither annihilation nor creation but transition of being from one state to another. Wherever there is change, it presupposes the reality of that which changes. Therefore, there is permanence and there is change.
1.2 Statement Of The Problem
The philosophical debate as to whether change or permanence will take the upper hand over the other is a problem that cannot be over looked in philosophical discipline at all times. Hence, the problem at stake here is how true is it that what we call change really takes place? And why things will remain the same despite the occurrence of change? This central question provoked many others, thus how can one and the same entity turn into that which it previously was not? If everything changes all the time, could there actually be any permanence, real, unchanging feature of the universe? And if reality were actually unchanging and unchangeable, how could it have any thing to do with the apparent world of change and how could it explain the world of change.
Commenting on this, Egbeke Aja states that,
As early philosophers explored these problems, it seemed to them that change and permanence were incompatible, and that reality had to be one or the other, either ever changing or completely permanent.9
This originated because of the conflict between our sense perception and that made by the intellect. The intellect sees reality as one while the senses grasp reality as many and always in flux. But how can we reconcile this apparent contradiction between our sense perception of reality and that given by our intellect?
In all, two basic problems could be deduced from this topic, namely
- Must we take seriously both multiplicity and the oneness of being or can we affirm one aspect and dissolve the other as mere appearance, illusion, or projection of the mind?
- If we take both aspects seriously, how are they co-possible? What kind of unity is involved? How can the unity and diversity be harmonized?
Confronted with this philosophical problem of change, Aristotle posited his doctrine of act and potency, Hylemorphism and categories as a solution. Thus, these doctrines arose as an attempt by Aristotle to provide a lasting solution to the problem of change and permanence, which had challenged philosophy for a century and a half. But did he actually succeed? This is actually the problem that motivated this research.
1.3 Purpose Of The Study
It is the answer to these arrays of thought provoking questions that this paper is geared to find. It is the search for the most fundamental truth about this world. Truth about reality never completely manifests itself at an instance but through a process of gradual unfolding. This paper inquires into the origin of the problem of change and permanence, and then will investigate the views offered by two great philosophers of timeless repute, Heraclitus and Parmenides. Further, it studies in a more detailed manner the solutions offered by one of the greatest genius, Aristotle. Lastly, the tremendous impact of his thought on practical life will be viewed.
1.4 Scope Of The Study
Cognizance of Aristotle’s vast contribution and discussion in philosophy, the scope of this study is based on his mediation on the problem of change and permanence. His key concept to this realization is the unification of the Parmenidean and Heraclitean positions. His notion of Act and potency, Hylemorphism and categories should be highlighted though in relation to Parmenides and Heraclitus’ perspectives. To make the study scholarly and easy to comprehend, the nature of change and permanence are to be discussed.
1.5 Methodology
The work is expository and analytic. Heraclitus’ and Parmenides’ concept of change and permanence shall be exposed with their views and reasons. Then, in the light of these expositions, the notion of change and permanence in Aristotle’s perspective shall be analyzed. In approaching this topic for a better apprehension, it is divided into four chapters. Chapter one explicates the background, aim, scope, problem and method of the study. In chapter two, the concepts of change and permanence, which will focus simply on the etymological derivation of the two terms and on their elucidation and explication, will be discussed.
The historical perspective of Parmenides and Heraclitus who were extremists in their treatment of the subjects of change and permanence will be viewed in the same chapter. Chapter three deals with Aristotle’s mediation between the two positions with his doctrine of Act and Potency, matter and form (Hylemorphism), and substantial and accidental change (Categories). In chapter four, the whole exposition will be evaluated which will also touch on the influence the resourcefulness of Aristotle’s philosophical mind had on the practical life. This will be followed by a general conclusion
CHAPTER TWO
2.0 Literature Review
2.1 Introduction
The review of relevant literature is the main topic of this chapter. A literature review covers theoretical and methodological contributions to a certain issue in addition to the state of knowledge at the time of writing. It provides information about the state of the art in relation to the subject you are writing about. It examines the body of work on the chosen subject. The literature evaluation in this study comprises the …
Procedure for Downloading the PDF (Docx) Material
Aristotle’s notion on change and permanence can be downloaded by requesting the full set of materials at the project or seminar cost. The document will be sent via Microsoft Word (MS-Word) format via WhatsApp (e-mail) following payment confirmation.
Seminar Material Cost ₦3,000 | Project Material Cost ₦5,000 |
Request Complete Material
![]() | Click here to request the Complete Material via WhatsApp including;
|
Disclaimer for Complete Material Utilization
The displayed research work titled "Aristotle's notion on change and permanence" is stated as a research guideline towards accomplishing your assigned project / seminar research work. All the research materials on this website are ONLY for research purposes and should be used as a guideline in developing your research work. For no reason should you copy word for word as projectlist.com.ng will not be liable for any who copied the material. By ordering the complete research guideline, it signifies that you've accepted our terms of service.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Can the material for “Effect of Automated Teller Machine (ATM) on the Performance of Nigerian Banks” be used as a guide for Banking and Finance (BF) Project?
Yes it can be used — Automated Teller Machine (ATM) refers to a machine that acts as a bank teller by receiving and issuing money to and from the Automated Teller Machine account holders/users. The study was carried out to investigate the Effect of Automated Teller Machine on the Performance of Nigerian Banks. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out to determine to what extent an Automated Teller Machine stimulate growth of banking system, find out the extent to which Automated Teller Machine speedily improve banking profitability and determine the extent to which Automated Teller Machine ATM influence fraud in banking sector. The research design used in this report is descriptive design, utilizing questionnaire method to obtain information from the respondents for …
Can the material for “The Role of the Financial Investors in Housing Provisioning in Nigeria” be used as a guide for Environmental Science Project?
Yes it can be used — Housing plays a key role in the socio-economic development of every country but unfortunately, housing supply worldwide has not been able to meet demand. The inadequate housing is one of the biggest challenges facing both developed and developing countries today with finance being a crucial factor. The financial Investors is the largest housing supply system but has not been able to meet the increasing demand partly as a result of the inadequate and ineffective financial mechanisms for financing housing in the country. The study therefore investigated the major finance mechanisms used by the financial Investors and factors which hinder their access to formal credit facilities. It also made suggestions to improve access to credit facilities to the financial Investors to …
Is the topic “Effect of Automated Clearing System on Bank Performance in Banking” recommended for Banking and Finance (BF) Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — To start with, the goal of every operation staff is to deliver quality service and in the process excite the customer. Through information given it is obvious that automated clearing system in Nigeria has improved payment service. The purpose of clearing banks to make the process more manageable. Method used in this project work has been arranged and design in a meaningful way so that it will be obvious to anybody that come across this project. The effect of automated clearing system has been stated in a clear times like strong of data and vital information. It also promoted effective control through tracking and reconciling items and also the benefit of the system has also been stated in a event between automated …
Can the material for “Open Defecation and Its Effect on the Human Health and Environment” be used as a guide for Environmental Science Project?
Yes it can be used — Open defecation is the act of passing excreta in open air locations instead of in hygienic, covered locations. Efforts to eradicate open defecation and improve sanitation access are unlikely to achieve health benefits unless interventions reduce microbial exposures. The aim of the study is to assess the Open Defecation and Its Effect on the Human Health and Environment. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out to assess the relationship between sanitation practices and the bacteriological quality of drinking water sources, determine the risk factors contributing to open defecation in the rural environments of the study area, and assess the water quality index and multivariate analysis for groundwater quality assessment of villages of rural in Delta State. …
Can the material for “Examination of Parental Attitudes Towards the Education of the Physically Challenge Children” be used as a guide for Physical Education Project?
Yes it can be used — Physically challenged child may be defined as a child who has disability of locomotors or neurological origin which constitutes disadvantages or restrictions in one or more aspect of daily living activities. The study was carried out to examine the Parental Attitudes towards the Education of the physically Challenge Children. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out to examine the parental attitude and measure the difference in parent’s attitude towards physically handicapped children. The research design used in this report is descriptive design, utilizing questionnaire method to obtain information from the respondents for this project. Primary data were collected from the primary source which questionnaire was used as an instrument of data collection while secondary data were …
Can the material for “The Need for Accounting Education in Small Scale Industries” be used as a guide for Accounting Education Project?
Yes it can be used — The face is generally recognized that small scales industries constane the major of business organization in Nigeria. The problem tend to investment of the investigate, the small scale industries the propose of carrying that this study is ascertains of the necessary for small scale industries to acquire knowledge effectively. In this study, the research tries to fund out if there is any relationship between accounting and management to small scale industries. The result finding also showed that small scale industries play, important role in an economy that be courtants managers of small scale industries will increase their managerial skill if they acquire some training in accounting while attending summers. The research sees accounting as can in enable knowledge in the management of small …
Is the topic “A Survey of the Antibacterial Activity of Thymus Vulgaris and Myristica Fragrans on Streptococuss Pneumoniae and Pseudomonas Aeruginosa” recommended for Microbiology Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — The aqueous and ethanolic extracts of the leaves of Thymus vulgaris (thyme) and the seeds of Myristica fragrans (nutmeg) were screened for their antibacterial activity and phytochemical constituents. The standard methods used to detect the phytochemicals present in the extracts revealed the presence of tannins, flavonoids, triterpenoids and phytosterols in all the extracts while steroids and amino acids were absent. The antibacterial evaluation of the spice extracts using agar plate-well diffusion and nutrient broth dilution techniques showed that there was no significant difference in the activity of the spice extracts (p > 0.05) against the test organisms (Streptococcus pneumoniaeand Pseudomonas aeruginosa, clinical bacterial isolates). Ampiclox and chloramphenicol were used as control for the test organisms to provide approximate basis for …
Is the topic “The Effects of Militancy on Development of the Nigeria State” recommended for Political Science Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — For so many years, the Niger Delta Region has been oppressed by the Military and Civilian Government. This research work examines the effect of Militancy on the Development of the Nigeria states. It relied on secondary source such as books, journals, newspaper articles. It focuses on damage and the negativity as a result of the operation of the militant. Also attempt on how the crises can be solve. This is mainly by creating Jobs and equitable sharing of the resources. The research therefore recommends that the administration of YarAdua should as a matter of urgency create a welfare package people of Niger Delta by creating Jobs and building of industries in the region. …
Can the material for “The Role of Central Bank of Nigerian in the Management of the Nations Foreign Debt” be used as a guide for Banking and Finance (BF) Project?
Yes it can be used — The central bank of Nigerian (C.B.N) started full-scale operation on 1st July 1959, and since its inception like most of the central bank the world over, performs certain national and international functions one of which is the management of foreign debt. So this project examines the role of CBN in the management of foreign debt. A lot of problems engulfed the central bank of Nigeria which trying to carry out this function ranging from inadequate reserves to over increasing imports bills. The study which is not one outcome of empirical research examines the different measures adopted by the central bank of Nig at different times to ensure efficient management of external debt. The methodology employed revolves round the use of secondary data …
Can this topic “The Influence of Information Communication Technology (ICT) on Moral Behaviours of Secondary School Students” be used for Information Technology Project?
Yes it can be utilized for research — The study examined the influence of information communication technology (ICT) on moral behaviours of adolescents in secondary schools in Oshodi Local Government Area of Lagos State. In this study also, relevant and extensive literature review was carried out under some sub-headings. Three null hypotheses were formulated and tested in this study, using the independent t-test statistical tool at 0.05 level of significance was used to analyse the data collected. The descriptive research survey design was used in the assessment of the respondents’ opinions using the questionnaire titled “Influence of Information Communication Technology (ICT) on Moral Behaviour of Adolescence”, stratified random sampling technique was used to select the sample. Also, a total of 200 (two hundred) respondents were selected and used as …