A CRITICAL EVALUATION OF ARISTOTLE'S CONCEPTION OF CAUSALITY

ABSTRACT

Causality has been variously defined, and even given an empirical understanding. Causality is derived from the term “cause which means anything capable of changing something else or that which “produces something (makes something happen; bring about the occurrence of something) without which that thing would not have resulted. That which is produced (or changed) is called the effect and the effect is explained by it cause. Nevertheless, in the treatment of causality Aristotle in his first philosophy or metaphysics gave a holistic analysis of the concept of causality, were he uses the term “cause” to mean explanation. However, for the Africans, “cause” has meaning basically from a metaphysical approach. That every effect has a cause is a very strong belief in the African world view. This means that whatever happens physically or otherwise has an explanation and this explanation may be spiritual as well as natural. Nevertheless, this work attempts a critique of Aristotle’s analysis of causality.

CHAPTER ONE

General Introduction

1.1 Background To The Study

The problem of causality has been among the central concerns of many thinkers. When certain events happen, we tend to ask ‘why’. This is because such events produce some effects. In asking the question ‘why’, we are asking for the cause of the event. We seek an explanation that would enable us understand the effect which the event produces. This explains the whole problem and notion of causality. The Ionian philosophers probably the earliest thinkers did not fail to recognize that the world as it is did not come to be without being caused by some other things.

The Ionian philosophers occupied themselves with the cosmological problem; of what substance is the universe composed? This of course was a causal question and Thales of Miletus; the first Greek philosopher posited that the primary stuff of the cosmos was ‘water’1 Anaximander, criticizing the causal theory of his predecessor held the stuff of the universe is an indefinite or boundless realm.2 Anaximenes the third and last Milesian philosopher designated air as the primary substance from which all things come.3 These philosophers certainly did not regard the universe as anything other than an effect which requires a cause in order to be. Plato equally had his version of causality which was deeply rooted in his philosophy. For Plato, the sensible world is the changing world of appearance.

In a more interesting way, the belief is a strong one among the Africans. The Africans see everything that happens to him or her as an effect of something external to him or her, his or her misfortunes are attributed to the next door neighbour who wished him bad the other day, his or her poor harvest is traceable to the anger of the gods. African thought however explains causality without actually bifurcating the metaphysical from the phenomena. In other words, the African world is one, and every effect or event in the Africa universe is explainable only with reference to a cause. Let us present statement of the problem.

1.2 Statement Of The Problem

Aristotle in his First Philosophy or Metaphysics formulated the principle of causality through the study of man-made or artificial things and identified four types of causes. In Aristotle’s view, all the four causes (not a single one alone) are needed in order to produce an effect in art as well as in nature. The four causes include the formal cause (the shape or form of a thing) contributes, according to him, the “essence” of a thing. Material cause is the subject of change. Efficient cause is that which initiates activity. (The efficient cause is often known as the propelling cause.), The Final cause is the end (purpose, goal, state of completion) for which the change is produced. From the above, let us provide a problematization by ostention. When we see a rolling stone, we reason that the stone could not have caused its own movement. Then we begin to raise questions on how the stone came to be moved. This is obviously the problem with causal theory. We want to know ‘how’ A is the cause of B, and whether without A, there will not be B. This problem has dominated the discussion on causation. However, Aristotle tied the notion of cause to four factors and then believed that the, ‘Formal cause’ is the unifying force of the causes. The problematic of Aristotle’s idea of causality can be formulated thus;

How can matter or form bring about change?
If form contains within itself its own activity, do we still need a first mover (Efficient causation)?
Does passivity actually lead to change?

Nonetheless, we find that matter except acted upon cannot bring a change in itself, yet Aristotle consider the material cause as justified. The question remains, whether the four causes must be present for change to take place, or for something to come to be. The problem is, are there things that are not observed that can cause observed things? How can we balance the fact that both the material and immaterial can operate both as causes and effects. There are questions that our study of Aristotle needs to provide answers to. Let us present the methodology.

1.3 Methodology

The method to be used in this study would be analytical. It means that we shall analyze the concept of causality by simplifying or clarifying the term causality. Here we are interested in the meaning of causality, its history and specifically the Aristotelian conception of it. The actual instruments we wish to use include internet sources, archival materials, source documents, etc. Let us present the scope.

1.4 Scope Of The Study

The scope of this research work shall take into cognizance, the work of Aristotle on causality and some other ideas of causality. We now move to the purpose.

1.5 Purpose Of The Study

Our experience of reality both in its generality and in its specificities, confirms the physical theory that nature abhors vacuum. At the causal level, i.e., at the level of the relationship of things as they are products of other things, nature abhors ‘non causality’. The purpose of this project therefore, is to reflect on Aristotelian conception which seems to be radically different from his predecessors.

David Hume criticized the traditional conception of causality propounded by Aristotle. Our Second purpose here therefore is to show that Hume’s critic of Aristotle’s conception does not hold water. Above all, the ‘why’ question is an inevitable one because it seeks all-round and ontological response to the reason, explanation and justification of reality. Not just the way it happened, but the reason why it came to happen that way. It is concerned with ontological ultimacy, the last ground of explanation. The above three points mentioned above constitute the purpose of this project. We now proceed to the significance.

1.6 Significance Of The Study

The significant of anything lies in its value or relevance. Theoretically, this work is significant in a number of ways. Firstly, it asserts that there is reason for all things. This goes to show that every effect must have a cause, in Aristotelian terminology, “ex nihilo nihil fit” (from nothing, nothing comes). The significance here lies in the fact that it amounts to standing logic on the head, if we claim that effect are not ontologically linked with a causal principle. The second significant lies in the fact that human reason cannot rest until it finds answers to the curiosities that impinge on his consciousness.

According to Aristotle it is the nature of man to know and to ask questions. It is therefore doubly significant first negatively to escape from ignorant and positively to know the causes of things. Lastly Aristotelian conception of causality is significant because it attempts to give an explanation of the totality of reality through inductive and deductive processes. The question of origin is a very serious question. Aristotle in his theory of causes, to a large extent was able to give us a rational foundation of reality in totality. We now move to the literature review.

…

CHAPTER TWO

2.0 Literature Review

2.1 Introduction

The review of relevant literature is the main topic of this chapter. A literature review covers theoretical and methodological contributions to a certain issue in addition to the state of knowledge at the time of writing. It provides information about the state of the art in relation to the subject you are writing about. It examines the body of work on the chosen subject. The literature evaluation in this study comprises the …

Procedure for Downloading the PDF (Docx) Material

A Critical Evaluation of Aristotle’s Conception of Causality can be downloaded by requesting the full set of materials at the project or seminar cost. The document will be sent via Microsoft Word (MS-Word) format via WhatsApp (e-mail) following payment confirmation.

Seminar Material Cost
₦3,000

Project Material Cost
₦5,000

Request Complete Material

Complete Material Chapters of A Critical Evaluation of Aristotles Conception of Causality

Click here to request the Complete Material via WhatsApp including;

Preliminary Pages,
Chapter 1-5,
References and Appendix.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
PRELIMINARY PAGES

Title page
Approval page
Dedication
Acknowledgement
Table of Contents
Abstract
CHAPTER ONE
General Introduction
1.1 Background of the Study
1.2 Statement of the Problem
1.3 Methodology
1.4 Scope of the Study
1.5 Purpose of the Study
1.6 Significance of the Study
1.7 Literature Review
Notes and REFERENCES
CHAPTER TWO:
The General Philosophy Of Aristotle
2.1 Background of Aristotle
2.2 His Theory of Logic
2.3 His Theory of Knowledge
2.4 His Theory of Metaphysics
2.5 His Theory of Ethics
2.6 His Theory of Politics
Notes and REFERENCES
CHAPTER THREE:
An Analysis Of Aristotle’S Conception Of Causality.
3.1 The Meaning of Causality
3.2 Aristotle’s Metaphysics as a Foundation
3.3 Aristotle’s Conception of Causality
3.4 Formal Cause
3.5 Material Cause
3.6 Efficient Cause
3.7 Final Cause
Notes and REFERENCES
CHAPTER FOUR:
Evaluation And Conclusion
4.1 Summary of the Main Points
4.2 Some Merits of Aristotle’s Theory
4.3 Some Demerits of Aristotle’s Theory
4.4 Causality in a Post Aristotle’s Era
Notes and REFERENCES
Conclusion
BIBLIOGRAPHY

Disclaimer for Complete Material Utilization
The displayed research work titled "A Critical Evaluation of Aristotle's Conception of Causality" is stated as a research guideline towards accomplishing your assigned project / seminar research work. All the research materials on this website are ONLY for research purposes and should be used as a guideline in developing your research work. For no reason should you copy word for word as projectlist.com.ng will not be liable for any who copied the material. By ordering the complete research guideline, it signifies that you've accepted our terms of service.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can the material for “Students Perception Towards the Teaching of Sexuality Education in Secondary Schools” be used as a guide for Guidance and Counselling Project?

Yes it can be used — The purpose of this study was to determine whether sexuality education should be inculcated into the secondary school curriculum and at what level of study.. The descriptive survey research method was used for the study. A total of five hundred (500) participants were selected through a simple random sampling technique which comprised the sample population. The research instrument used was a self-developed and validated questionnaire. Five (5) research questions and hypotheses were raised and tested in this study. Data analysis was with descriptive statistics of frequency counts, percentages and the inferential statistics chi-Square (X) statistics was used for Hypotheses testing. Results showed that all hypotheses were rejected. Findings revealed that there is a significant relationship between content of sex education, …

Is the topic “Comparative Analysis of Emecheta’s Second Class Citizen and Nwapa’s Efuru” recommended for Linguistics and Communication Project?

Yes it is highly recommended — This study undertakes a comparative analysis of the works of two Nigerian female novelists: Buchi Emecheta and Flora Nwapa, it looks at the contemporary African society which is dominated by men.Little or no recognition is given to women thus they have been oppressed, depressed, subjected and neglected. In this regards African female writers like Buchi Emecheta, Flora Nwapa, Ama Ata Aidoo, Mariama Ba, Zaynab Alkali among others fought on behalf of African women through their works by giving them significant roleswhich portray women as a virtue and instrument of honour in the Africa society. …

Can this topic “Influence of Nigerian Television Authority (N.T.A.) Enugu in Improving Rural Health Care Services” be used for Public Health Project?

Yes it can be utilized for research — This study examines the influence of N.T.A Enugu in improving rural health care services in Ugwuaji community in carrying out this research both primary and secondary data were used and the researcher made use of sample size of 360 respondents across the local government area. Descriptive statistics were used and the findings showed that N.T.A play notable roles in improving rural health care services by informing the government on the poor state of health services on Ugwuaji community as noted by 27.8% of respondents sensitizing, the rural populace (Ugwuaji community to appreciate and participate on government health programmes as noted by 47.22% of respondents mobilizing the masses for positive actions towards health improvement e.g environmental sanitation nutrition e.t.c as noted …

Can this topic “The Effects of Working Capital Management on the Profitability of an Organization” be used for Business Administration and Management (BAM) Project?

Yes it can be utilized for research — This study titled ‘influence of working capital management on profitability of companies; issues, challenges and strategies examined the various ways by which working capital can be managed to enhance profitability, evaluate the need for the management of working capital, and also identified the hindrances to proper management of account receivables in seeking for information needed for the study , primary and secondary means of data collections were adopted such as oral interview, questionnaires and simple size observation, ESUT library and internet played a great role in data collection. The Taro Yamane’s formula was use in determining the chi-square statistic was adopted in presentation and analysis of data. Findings showed that proper management of account receivable aids efficient and effective operations …

Can the material for “The Impact of Information and Communication Technology on School Administration Process in Senior Secondary School” be used as a guide for Information Technology Project?

Yes it can be used — The study was carried out to examine the Impact of Information and Communication Technology on School Administration Process in Senior Secondary School. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out to find out the available ICT resources in performing core administrative duties and investigate the principals’ perception of the use of ICT resources in performing administrative tasks. The research design used in this report is descriptive design, utilizing questionnaire method to obtain information from the respondents for this project. A total of 200 (two hundred) respondents were selected for this study to represent the entire population of the study. For null hypotheses were formulated and tested using the one-way ANOVA and the t-test statistical tools at zero …

Is the topic “Assessment of Revenue Generation and Service Delivery” recommended for Public Administration (PA) Project?

Yes it is highly recommended — Every local government in Nigeria desires quality service delivery as it is pertinent to the sustainability of grassroots development. The fundamental factor in achieving quality services, are adequate and reliable of the revenue sources as well as quality human resources that will serve as instrument for formulation and implementation of local government financial resources. This study assessed revenue generation and service delivery in Nigeria, a study of Abuja Municipal and Abaji Area Councils of Federal Capital Territory from 2008 -2013; arising as a result of low service delivery in Abaji specifically in health care and environmental sanitation services. The objective of the study is to make comparative assessment of actual revenue generated by the two area councils and how the …

Can the material for “Design and Implementation of an Online BVN Generating System” be used as a guide for Computer Science (CS) Project?

Yes it can be used — Bank Verification Number (BVN) is the 11digit number you get from the bank after your picture, fingerprints, and signature have been captured electronically and successfully added to the database. The aim of the study is to design and implement an Online BVN Generating System for Nigerians in the Diaspora and at home to use. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out as follows to develop an application software that will examine the benefits of adopting an online BVN system and identify the necessary structures needed to run a successful online BVN system. The motivation that led to the implementation of the proposed system is that in the existing system, fraud and money laundering have had adverse impacts …

Can this topic “Effects of Business Environment on the Productivity of Business Organizations in Nigeria” be used for Business Administration and Management (BAM) Project?

Yes it can be utilized for research — Business Environment is described as a formal system of co-ordination activities of a group of people working co-operatively towards a common goal, under authority and leadership. The aim of the study is to identify the effects of business environment on the productivity of business organization. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were set out to determine the level of competition so as to know whether environment is favorable or unfavorable, and find out if the company has a good relationship with customers and what effect has on business. The research design used in this report is descriptive design, utilizing questionnaire method to obtain information from the respondents for this project. Primary data were collected from the primary source …

Can the material for “Challenges of Tax Administration” be used as a guide for Accountancy / Accounting Project?

Yes it can be used — This study was carried out to find out the challenges of tax administration in selected local government areas of Edo state. The population of this study comprises tax administrators and taxpayers in these local government areas. Data collected were presented with the use of simple percentages and the hypotheses were tested with the Z-test. Findings from this study reveal that improper maintenance of taxpayers and inadequate logistics arrangement for tax collection/assessment was the major challenges of tax administration. …

Can the material for “Corruption and Underdevelopment in Nigerian Public Service” be used as a guide for Political Science Project?

Yes it can be used — This work is prompted by the desire to fathom corruption and underdevelopment in Nigerian public service. (a study of Anambra state).as a modest contribution of the federal government declared to eradicate corruption in our society. furthermore, in data collected primary together with secondary sources used by the researcher were got through questionnaire and interviews with the Anambra state Public servants, while secondary data were collected from books, journals, newspaper and other written materials from the analysis and discussions, the following findings were made, corruption is the major issue and it has its causes, consequences and solutions one of the major, corruption causes under development, corruption equally causes employment, the following steps should be taken to alleviate the problem associated to …