A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF JOHN RAWLS' SECOND PRINCIPLE OF JUSTICE
ABSTRACT
John Rawls’ “A theory of justice” published in 1971, changed contemporary political theory. In the book, John Rawls presented a reformulation of the social contract theory of John Locke, Jean Jacque Rosseau and Immanuel Kant, providing a justification of the liberal state.
According to John Rawls, parties to a contract in an original position would accept two principles of justice to regulate the basic structure of society.
The two principles are;
Each person is to have an equal right to the most extensive system of equal liberties compatible with a similar system of liberty for all.
Social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are both;
- To the greatest benefit of the least advantaged, consistent with the just saving principle
- Attached to offices and positions open to all under conditions of fair equality of opportunity.
The second principle being my point of focus, can be better understood in two categories, which are; fair equality of opportunity and the difference principle.
John Rawls second principle of justice can be seen as a distributive justice.
The aim of this work is to critically examine John Rawls second principle of justice, looking at the positive and negative aspects of the second principle of justice according to John Rawls.
The method that will be employed will be the analytic critical method because that will seem as the best method if one is to properly analyse John Rawls second principle of justice and thoroughly criticize it.
CHAPTER ONE
General Introduction
Background Of Study
In the history of philosophy, the issue of justice has always been a serious debate. The debate is all about what the concept ‘justice’ means and how it can be attained in a society. Thrasymachus, an ancient Greek philosopher, equated justice with ‘‘might is right’’. According to Christopher Stolleri, ‘’Justice is a concept that is balanced between law and morality’’1. Morality has to do with the rightness or wrongness of an action. Laws are laid down principles that guide a society and they can be used for the good or bad of a nation’s citizens. For Joseph Omoregbe, ‘’the foundation of Justice is the fundamental equality of all men’’2. Justice is applied in a society so that there will be peace and harmony in the society. A society is an aggregate of people living together in a more or less ordered community.
From this, various philosophers gave their various theories of how justice can be attained in the society.
Socrates, a Greek philosopher, felt that justice can be attained in a society when wisdom is employed. For Plato, it is when philosophers are kings in the society. According to Karl Marx, a just society is a classless society which he referred to as communism. John Stuart Mill and Jeremy Bentham are of the view that we arrive at a just society when the society acts to provide ‘’the greatest good for the greatest number’.
John Rawls provided his own theory of justice by criticizing the utilitarian view of justice because it can be abused, leading to the ‘’tyranny of the majority’’ (Nazi Germany’s mistreatment of the Jews and the United States mistreatment of African Americans)3. Rawls’ approach guards against this common source of injustice.
Principles of justice are the principles that rational and free persons that are concerned to further their interests would accept in an initial position of equality as defining fundamentals of the term of their association.4 In his book, ‘A Theory of Justice’, like Plato, Rawls imagines a political society structured on principles of justice, a just society where nobody complains of injustice, a society governed by principles of justice.
From the above, John Rawls came up with his own idea of a just society by providing two principles that can guide a society to attain the state of a just society. He did this by giving a theory of the people in the original position wearing a veil of ignorance that they would not be partial. One of John Rawls’ primary aim was to set forth the appropriate moral conception that was better suited to interpreting the democratic values of freedom and equality than the reigning utilitarian tradition.
It is in the light of this background that my research intends to critically analyze the principles that John Rawls gave to guide us to a just society. In order to achieve this, I shall consider the following: the people of the original position, the veil of ignorance and the principles accepted, mainly focusing on his second principle of justice.
1.2 Statement Of The Problem
The second principle states that: social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are both (a) to the greatest benefit of all the least advantaged, consistent with the just saving principle, (b) attached to offices and positions open to all under conditions of fair equality of opportunity.
Various problems arise, for instance, can there ever really be equal opportunities given the fact that nature itself is not equal? Is it fair for things to be shared equally when people do not give the same quota to the society? How do the individuals gain possession of goods?
Although John Rawls’ principle of justice is an improvement from some other solutions to the problem of justice, the question is, can we say that John Rawls’ second principle of justice is adequate in guiding a society to a state where it can be regarded as a just society? Can it be universally accepted? These questions are the core areas of this study.
1.3 Scope Of The Study
This study will focus primarily on John Rawls’ second principle of justice, but before then, I shall view the steps that led to accepting the principle and I shall also give a critique of John Rawls’ second principle of justice.
Although my research will be far and wide, the scope of this study however shall be limited entirely on John Rawls second principle of justice.
1.4 Purpose Of The Study
This study aims at providing better understanding of John Rawls second principle of justice, by analyzing it. There will also be a critique of John Rawls’ second principle of justice so that the tenability of the principle can be assessed. By understanding John Rawls’ second principle of justice better and viewing the various critiques, we can finally be able to evaluate and pass a judgment if it can really guide a society to becoming a just society.
1.5 Significance Of Study
This study helps to give a full understanding of John Rawls’ second principle of justice, taking note of its positive and negative side without accepting it dogmatically. Rawls argues that his principles of justice should be used to assess the justice of actual social institutions, such as political government that govern human being.
We can decide if John Rawls’ second principle can guide a society into a just society. With this project, after critically analyzing John Rawls’ second principle of justice, we can decide for ourselves if it is the answer to the problem of our present day society or if it is just another theory to be disregarded.
1.6 Method Of Study
In this project, I shall employ the analytical cum critical method. I shall rely on data collection from text books, articles, journals, the internet and any other source relevant to this project topic. This method will help us to fully understand John Rawls’ second principle of justice and pose some critical question.
1.7 Literature Review
The first book reviewed is authored by John Rawls himself, titled “Theory of Justice’’ published in 1971 by Harvard University Press. I reviewed this book for the obvious reason that it was written by John Rawls himself. This book gave us a firsthand view of John Rawls’ principle of justice.
Another book reviewed is by Samuel Freeman titled “Rawls” published in 2007 by Freeman, projected an understanding of Rawls’ work. He gave attention to every detail and this is as a result of his awareness of the overall structure of theory and the philosophical significance of Rawls’ grand strategy.
I also reviewed a book by Joseph Omoregbe titled “Social-Political Philosophy and International Relations” published in 2007 Lagos. This book gave an in depth meaning of justice, it also emphasized the idea of distributive justice in which John Rawls second principle of justice can be classified under. From there, Omoregbe breaks down John Rawls’ idea of the principle of justice.
Another book that was reviewed is by Paul Graham titled “Rawls” published in 2007 by One World thinkers. In this book, Paul Graham gave his own interpretation and understanding of John Rawls’ work.
I also reviewed a book by Stumpf and Abel titled “Elements of philosophy” published in 2002 by McGraw-Hill. This book gives a clear and simple explanation of John Rawls’ book. “A theory of justice”, give extracts from the book.
Another of Joseph Omoregbe’s book “A Simplified History of Western Philosophy” was also reviewed. It was published in 1991 at Ikeja, Lagos. This book gave a more elaborate understanding of John Rawls principles of justice, by giving us the four systems which Rawls examine to see which of them is conducive to the realization of the second principle which demands that the least advantaged the poor, is always favoured by any change or socio-economic arrangement in society.
CHAPTER TWO
2.0 Literature Review
2.1 Introduction
The review of relevant literature is the main topic of this chapter. A literature review covers theoretical and methodological contributions to a certain issue in addition to the state of knowledge at the time of writing. It provides information about the state of the art in relation to the subject you are writing about. It examines the body of work on the chosen subject. The literature evaluation in this study comprises the …
Procedure for Downloading the PDF (Docx) Material
A Critical Analysis of John Rawls’ Second Principle of Justice can be downloaded by requesting the full set of materials at the project or seminar cost. The document will be sent via Microsoft Word (MS-Word) format via WhatsApp (e-mail) following payment confirmation.
| Seminar Material Cost ₦3,000 | Project Material Cost ₦5,000 |
Request Complete Material
 | Click here to request the Complete Material via WhatsApp including;
|
TABLE OF CONTENTSPRELIMINARY PAGES
- Title page
- Approval page
- Dedication
- Acknowledgement
- Table of Contents
- Abstract
- General Introduction
- Background of study
- Statement of problem
- Scope of study
- Purpose of study
- Significance of study
- Method of study
- Literature review
- Endnotes
- What Lead To John Rawls Second Principle Of Justice.
- 2.1 The original position
- 2.2 The veil of ignorance
- 2.3 Principles accepted
- Endnotes
- John Rawls’ Second Principle Of Justice
- 3.1 Distributive justice
- 3.2 Fair equality of opportunity
- 3.3 The difference principle
- 3.4 The system conducive to the realization of the second principle of justice.
- Endnotes
- Critique Of John Rawls’ Second Principle Of Justice
- 4.1 Positive critique on John Rawls’ second principle of justice
- 4.2 Negative critique on John Rawls’ second principle of justice
- End notes
- 5.1 Summary
- 5.2 Evaluation
- 5.3 Conclusion
- Endnotes
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
Disclaimer for Complete Material Utilization
The displayed research work titled "A Critical Analysis of John Rawls' Second Principle of Justice" is stated as a research guideline towards accomplishing your assigned project / seminar research work. All the research materials on this website are ONLY for research purposes and should be used as a guideline in developing your research work. For no reason should you copy word for word as projectlist.com.ng will not be liable for any who copied the material. By ordering the complete research guideline, it signifies that you've accepted our terms of service.
PRELIMINARY PAGES
- Title page
- Approval page
- Dedication
- Acknowledgement
- Table of Contents
- Abstract
- General Introduction
- Background of study
- Statement of problem
- Scope of study
- Purpose of study
- Significance of study
- Method of study
- Literature review
- Endnotes
- What Lead To John Rawls Second Principle Of Justice.
- 2.1 The original position
- 2.2 The veil of ignorance
- 2.3 Principles accepted
- Endnotes
- John Rawls’ Second Principle Of Justice
- 3.1 Distributive justice
- 3.2 Fair equality of opportunity
- 3.3 The difference principle
- 3.4 The system conducive to the realization of the second principle of justice.
- Endnotes
- Critique Of John Rawls’ Second Principle Of Justice
- 4.1 Positive critique on John Rawls’ second principle of justice
- 4.2 Negative critique on John Rawls’ second principle of justice
- End notes
- 5.1 Summary
- 5.2 Evaluation
- 5.3 Conclusion
- Endnotes
- BIBLIOGRAPHY
Disclaimer for Complete Material Utilization
The displayed research work titled "A Critical Analysis of John Rawls' Second Principle of Justice" is stated as a research guideline towards accomplishing your assigned project / seminar research work. All the research materials on this website are ONLY for research purposes and should be used as a guideline in developing your research work. For no reason should you copy word for word as projectlist.com.ng will not be liable for any who copied the material. By ordering the complete research guideline, it signifies that you've accepted our terms of service.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is the topic “Design of Road Pavement Linking Mass Communication Department and Federal Secretariat Industrial Centre” recommended for Industrial Design Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — This research work was undertaken by the author, aimed at providing explanation of the basic theory of the work of road design and its associated activities also, to cover practical methods of working. In pursuit of the meaningful completion this project a lot of investigation was embarked with principles and practice of road construction. The total distance of route was determined and stations established bearing in mind the intervisibility of the stations. Leveling was carried out to obtain information on the profile of the route for proper earthwork knowledge which theodolite traversing was carried out to obtain the plan and horizontal alignment of the route Soil analysis, gave the proper constitute of the soil which was also carried out to …
Can the material for “Design and Implementation of an Expert Medical Diagnosis and Prescription System” be used as a guide for Computer Science (CS) Project?
Yes it can be used — As the need of system almost every activity man can perform increase, software for the admission of students into polytechnics should not be left out. This software can process the credentials of 1000 credentials in about 20 minutes higher one computer operator if provided with the required data and this would have taken about 4 people 12 hours to do. This project was borne out of the necessite to address the inherent problem encountered by staff of the admission department and students of Akanu Ibiam Federal Polytechnic Uwana, Afikpo. The manual processes involved in the admission of students were critically examined and the flows noted. The software often to a great extent, the solutions to these problems. The project went further to …
Can this topic “Feminist Attitude on the Dilemma of the Girl Child in African Culture” be used for English Language Project?
Yes it can be utilized for research — This research examines the dilemma of the girl child in African culture and the fundamental problems confronting her existential being. It explores the unfair treatment the girl-child receives in a male chauvinistic and particular society like Africa and the negative effects of such to her femininity. As a way of redeeming the dignity of the girl child and positioning her for a better life, emphasis is placed on the feminist approach and how such could be used to combat the various exploitative and unjust treatment most African societies subject the girl child to in the name of custom and tradition. Since, the discourse of feminism flows well with the objective of this research, efforts will therefore be made to extract …
Is the topic “The Effect of Training and Development on Employee Commitment” recommended for Business Administration and Management (BAM) Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — The study examined the training and development on employee commitment in Zenith Bank Plc, Nigeria. The study employed the survey design and the purposive sampling technique to select 450 staff across management, senior and junior level. A well-constructed questionnaire, which was adjudged valid and reliable, was used for collection of data from the respondents. The data obtained through the administration of the questionnaires was analyzed using the Pearson correlation analysis. The results showed that there is a positive and significant relationship between Mentoring has significant effect on employee commitment (r=0.772; p<0.05)., Also, a positive and significant relationship exists between Job Delegation and employee commitment (r=.896; p<0.05)., Furthermore, a positive and significant relationship exists between Job Empowerment and employee commitment (r=.896; …
Can this topic “Knowledge, Practice and Challenges of Exclusive Breastfeeding Among Working Class Women” be used for Midwifery Project?
Yes it can be utilized for research — Exclusive breastfeeding is the infant receives only breast milk and other liquids or solids are not given with the exception of oral rehydration solution or drops/syrups of vitamins, minerals or medicines. The study was carried out to examine the Knowledge, Practice and Challenges of Exclusive Breastfeeding among Working Class Women in Esan Local Government Secretariat, Ekpoma in Edo State. In achieving this aim, the following specific objectives were laid out to assess whether mother's age, level of education and occupation has influence on the practice of exclusive breastfeeding and investigate the problems encountered by working class women during exclusive breastfeeding of their child. Investigation revealed that the percentage of mothers practicing breastfeeding, it should not be surprising that Nigeria is …
Can the material for “The Problems and Prospects of Social Marketing in Nigeria Manufacturing Organisation” be used as a guide for Business Administration and Management (BAM) Project?
Yes it can be used — The aim of this research work is to appraise “problems and prospects of social marketing in Nigeria manufacturing organization. The objectives of this research work include the following; to investigate whether the Nigerian manufacturing sectors have an in-depth knowledge of social marketing practice. To investigate the problems encountered by Nigerian manufacturing sector in their social marketing sector. For a successful completion of this researcher made use of both primary and secondary methods of data collection for information gathering. Primary data were collected through questionnaire administration, oral interview, and personal observation. Secondary data were collected through periodicals and journals, textbooks and lecture note, books and internet. The data collected were presented in table and analyzed with simple percentages while the hypotheses stated were …
Is the topic “The Impact of Exchange Rate, Variation on Balance of Payment” recommended for Economics Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — This study, was carried out to ascertain the effect of exchange rate variation on balance of payment in Nigeria from (1979 − 2008) exchange rate and interest rate used as a proxy for the balance of payment in Nigeria. Policy makers and some researcher s argued on exchange rate variations having a significant factor. Some have found negative, positive, significant and insignificant result on the impact of exchange rate variations on the balance payment. The F − test result suggested that the model is statistically significant. Based on this work, using econometric test of co integration we achieved that there is positive and significant relationship between exchange rate and balance of payment in Nigerian economy. This means that the exchange rate …
Is the topic “Effect of Unemployment on the Economic Development of Nigeria” recommended for Business Administration and Management (BAM) Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — This research on ‘Effect of unemployment on the economic development of Nigeria, on Nkanu West Enugu State. The research work objectives to: identify factors that cause unemployment in Nigeria, investigate the extent to which government has helped in tackling unemployment problems in Nigeria, determine programmes that can help to tackle unemployment problems in Nigeria. The researcher adopted both primary and secondary means of data collection. The population of the study was randomly selected as 234 in number and the sample size is 148. The Taro Yamane’s formula was used, while chi-square was adopted in testing the hypotheses. The research work also made the following findings; the research study reveals that Unemployment impedes economic development in Nigeria, it was also discovered …
Is the topic “Developmental Impact of Rural Banking in Nigeria” recommended for Banking and Finance (BF) Project?
Yes it is highly recommended — This research work is aimed at bringing into light the Development impact of rural banking in Nigeria’s rural area and how it affects the economy in general. For the purpose of orderly presentation of relevant materials, the main body of this work has been divided into five chapters The first chapter which is the introduction consider among other things problems identification/statement of problems, Rational of the study, Significance of the Study, Background of the Study and Definitions of the Terms used. Chapter two (2) focuses on the literature review, Theoretical Review and Empirical Review which discusses on banking marketing awareness and acceptance, the social responsibilities facing banks, rural banking and agricultural development, rural banking scheme and evaluation of the rural banking scheme …
Can the material for “Analysis of Factors Responsible for Low Productivity of the Nigerian Workers” be used as a guide for Public Administration (PA) Project?
Yes it can be used — Branch (1975) was of the view that productivity means the continuing improvement of the firm management performance in the use of resources and though the operations it is conducted. However the purpose of this work highlights those factors responsible for low productivity among Nigerian workers. The research tends to focus on those means that will be applied to get workers committed to tier work using effective national tool to enhance and increase productivity level of the public organization, Nepa Enugu zonal office as the study scope. Data were collected from both primary and secondary sources, the analysis and secondary sources, the analysis of the research brought out a population size used to determine the basis for the information gathered and analyzed. The …